Gifts That Don't Stop Giving
Call: (315) 698-4330
Cicero, NY 13039

Gift Items in Cicero, New York

Don't worry if you've never been good at buying gifts-you can be much better at it when you buy from All Mixed Up. Shopping for a present for your loved one or friend is more fun with leather shoes and other quality gift items sold by our store in Cicero, New York. We have the largest Birkenstock selection in the area. Below, you'll find a detailed list of some of the gift items we sell.


•Birkenstock® Leather Shoes & Sandals
• Dr. Martins
• Special Orders Avaiable
• Minnetonka Moccasins & Sandals 
 • Minnetonka Slippers

Tobacco Accessories

• Glass Water Pipes
• Metal Grinders
• Wood Grinders
• Rolling Papers
• Zippo™ Lighters & Fluid
• Metal Cigarette Cases
   —Long & Short Cigarettes
• Cigar Cases


• Band Posters
• Art Posters
• Native American Posters
• "Alice in Wonderland"
• Sci-Fi Posters

* Small to Standard Sizes Available


• Leather Purses
• Satchels
• Small Cross-Body Bags
• Fabric Purses
• Clutches
• Purses with Designs or

* Majority Are Made in the USA


Leather Shoes in Cicero, NY

Walking Canes
Whether for a hiker who likes to discover Mother Nature or for an elderly relative, our canes make perfect gifts. All canes we sell are handmade from wood and include quality handles for more safety.

Contact our gift shop today in Cicero, New York, to place your first order for any of our outstanding gifts.